Interview by Abdullah Salam
NEW DELHI: John Dayal, former president of the All India Catholic Union and co-founder of the United Christian Forum, has criticised the proposed FCRA amendments, warning that they could threaten churches, charitable institutions and NGOs working with marginalised communities.
Dayal said the proposed bill could threaten charitable institutions and their assets, despite the government’s stated aim of ensuring transparency.
“If the government uses the term ‘transparency,’ I would say its actions transparently expose its attitude towards religious minorities, NGOs, dissent and those who reach out to the poor and marginalized,” Dayal told NNP News.
He also discussed reported attacks against Christians, the alleged misuse of anti-conversion laws and police inaction in hate-crime cases, calling for stronger constitutional protections and equal treatment of religious minorities.
“No community in any country can depend entirely on outsiders to ensure its safety. We must strengthen our own institutions, defend the Constitution and insist on the rule of law,” he said.
FCRA Bill and the Future of Charitable Institutions
Q: The government says the proposed Foreign Contribution amendment bill is about transparency and preventing the misuse of funds, not targeting any community. How do you respond?
John Dayal: If the government uses the term “transparency,” I would say its actions transparently expose its attitude towards religious minorities, NGOs, dissent and those who reach out to the poor and marginalized.
Church organisations have established institutions to serve people who often do not receive adequate government support. The contributions they receive come from charitable individuals and churches in India and abroad to help people in need. This money is intended for humanitarian work, not to destabilise the government or aggravate the domestic political situation.
If an organisation’s FCRA registration lapses or is cancelled, what could happen to its church, school or hospital in practice?
These institutions were not built with government money. They were established to reach people for whom the government is not doing enough, particularly in education, healthcare and empowerment.
The money that comes in is provided through the charity of churches and individuals, including those in Western countries and elsewhere. These contributions help poor people. They are not intended to destabilise the government.
What changes would you want the Joint Parliamentary Committee to make before the bill becomes law?
Firstly, in our representations, church organisations will demand that the bill be scrapped because, in our view, there is no need for it.
Secondly, the legislation must not operate retrospectively. Properties and ambulances purchased ten years ago should not suddenly be taken away.
Thirdly, we are concerned about provisions under which property could vest in a government organisation rather than remain with the church that established it. Religious and charitable organisations have built these institutions over many years through donations and public contributions. We believe their assets should not be placed under government control without adequate safeguards.
Have meetings between Christian leaders and Union Home Minister Amit Shah produced any assurances?
Whenever the government takes action concerning anti-conversion laws, foreign contributions or the management of schools, we make representations. We believe in democratic processes.
We submit memorandums, meet ministers and members of Parliament, and raise our concerns through constitutional channels. Christian leaders, bishops and parliamentarians have made these efforts, and some have also met the Prime Minister.
However, I do not believe the government has adequately responded to our concerns. We feel that our representations have largely gone unheard.
Do you think religious minorities are united in responding to government policies that they consider discriminatory?
When the Waqf Bill was brought in parliament, I was among the Christian leaders who spoke against government control over properties built over centuries by religious organisations.
The principle is that religious institutions should be able to manage their properties without unnecessary government interference. This applies to all religions, including Hinduism, Islam and Christianity.
I am concerned that government control over church properties could follow a pattern similar to the debates surrounding Muslim religious properties. These institutions have been built through the contributions of ordinary people, often over generations.
In my view, religious minorities must stand up for their rights while respecting the democratic and constitutional framework of the country.
What can religious minorities do to ensure their safety?
Christians, Muslims, Sikhs, Buddhists and other communities must not resort to violence. Violence is not the democratic way, nor is it the way to function in a republic.
We have several instruments available to us: negotiation, parliamentary democracy, representations to elected representatives, and peaceful protest. We can raise our concerns in Parliament, state assemblies and other forums created by the Constitution.
For Christians and Muslims, prayer is also a source of strength. We must seek wisdom for our rulers while continuing to use democratic means to defend our rights.
Hate Crimes and Religious Freedom
What patterns are you seeing in reported hate crimes against religious minorities, particularly Christians? Have they changed since 2014?
Hate crimes take many forms. One of the most concerning forms, in my view, is what I describe as institutionalised hate, where politicians, police, local administration and groups associated with Hindu nationalism allegedly act together against Christians and Muslims, and sometimes Sikhs.
I am concerned that laws, including anti-conversion laws, are being used in ways that disproportionately affect religious minorities. People face accusations and legal consequences for religious activities that they consider an expression of their faith.
I also believe that physical attacks, intimidation, inflammatory rhetoric and restrictions on religious practices contribute to an atmosphere of fear.
Why do you think hostility towards Christians and Muslims is increasing despite public statements supporting religious coexistence?
I believe there is a difference between what is said in public and what some communities experience on the ground.
I am concerned about political mobilisation against religious minorities and rhetoric suggesting that Christians and Muslims do not fully belong in India. Such attitudes contradict the vision of a country founded on equality and fraternity.
I have also expressed concern about the activities of organisations associated with Hindu nationalism and the pressure they can place on minority communities. These are serious issues that need to be addressed through constitutional institutions and the rule of law.
You have referred to reports of Christians being prevented from burying their dead in their villages in Chhattisgarh. Why is this particularly concerning?
The inability to bury a family member according to one’s faith is a serious violation of human dignity. I have raised concerns about reports of Christians being denied burial in their villages and about allegations that bodies have been exhumed. I am also concerned that local authorities have not always acted effectively to resolve these disputes.
Such incidents raise questions about whether people are receiving equal protection under the law. Every family should be able to perform the last rites of a loved one with dignity and without fear.
You have also raised concerns about caste-based disadvantages faced by Christians and Muslims. What is the issue?
Caste does not necessarily disappear when a person changes religion. People from historically disadvantaged caste communities may continue to experience social and economic discrimination after converting to Christianity or Islam.I believe this raises important questions about equality and access to government support. A person’s social disadvantage does not automatically disappear because of their religious identity.
We need to examine how constitutional guarantees and welfare policies can ensure that disadvantaged people are not unfairly excluded from opportunities and benefits.
According to reported figures, 834 incidents involving Christians were reported, but formal first information reports (FIRs) were registered in 342 cases. Why are FIRs not being registered in every case?
I am one of the founders of the United Christian Forum. We document reported incidents involving crimes against Christians, but the cases we record represent only a small part of the overall picture.
Not every incident is reported to us, and we cannot independently obtain evidence in every case. What we document is therefore only the tip of the iceberg.
I am concerned that, in some places, local police and administrative authorities do not respond adequately when Christians report attacks or intimidation. There are cases in which, according to our accounts, the victims themselves face police action instead of receiving protection.
People are then forced to approach higher courts to seek justice. Many cases are pursued in High Courts and, in some instances, the Supreme Court.
Justice should be available at the grassroots level. Citizens should not have to keep moving from one court to another to obtain the protection they are entitled to receive.
Reports suggest that at least 100 Christians are in jail on charges of forcible conversion, with bail reportedly denied in some cases. Do you know any of them personally?
I know many of them personally. In some cases, the circumstances of the arrests are deeply concerning.I have heard of women being arrested in connection with prayer gatherings, including prayers at birthday parties or beside someone who is ill. There have also been allegations involving gatherings for prayer, baptisms and weddings.
My concern is that ordinary religious activities can lead to accusations of conversion. When people are arrested, they may face difficulties securing bail.
Every case must be examined fairly. Allegations should be investigated properly, and the legal process must not be used to intimidate people who are exercising their religious freedom.
Which states concern you the most when it comes to reported incidents against Christians?
I would identify Uttar Pradesh and Chhattisgarh as particularly concerning, followed by Odisha. I am also concerned about Madhya Pradesh, Haryana, Bihar, Jharkhand, Maharashtra and other states.
The situation varies from place to place, but we need to ensure that every state provides equal protection to all citizens, regardless of their religion.
Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS) chief Mohan Bhagwat has made public remarks about Hindu-Muslim coexistence, yet reports of hostility against Christians and Muslims continue. How do you understand this contradiction?
I believe we must look beyond public statements and examine what is happening on the ground.I have argued that overseas visits by prominent Hindu nationalist leaders can also have political objectives, including mobilising support and influencing how India’s situation is perceived internationally.
My appeal to foreign governments is to examine the evidence for themselves. They have embassies in India and should be able to assess reports of religious violence, the treatment of minorities and the functioning of law enforcement agencies.
They should not rely solely on the statements of political leaders, whether those statements are reassuring or critical. They should examine the available facts independently.
If international bodies are not doing enough to address the concerns of Indian religious minorities, what can communities do to ensure their own safety?
We are not living in India with the expectation that Washington, London, Brussels or Moscow will come and save us.Our first source of strength is our faith. Our second is the Constitution of India, which protects not only religious minorities but all citizens.
The Constitution protects workers, tribal communities and people from different religious backgrounds. Its guarantees of liberty, equality and fraternity are essential to the security of every Indian.
I am not less equal than a Hindu, and no citizen should be treated as less equal because of their religion. The Constitution must protect everyone equally.
What message would you give to Christians who feel afraid or uncertain about their future?
If you are afraid, remember that faith can give you strength. I believe democracy itself is a gift, and we must continue to believe in democratic institutions.
We must believe that Parliament will hear us, that the courts will hear us, and that our elected representatives will respond to the people who elected them.
We must also believe in fraternity. There are many people in the Hindu community who support peaceful coexistence and who believe that every citizen deserves dignity and protection.
No community in any country can depend entirely on outsiders to ensure its safety. We must strengthen our own institutions, defend the Constitution and insist on the rule of law.
If there is no rule of law, no community can be secure. The protection of Christians and Muslims is therefore not separate from the protection of Hindus or any other community.
My appeal is to all Indians: let us collectively strengthen the rule of law so that we can live peacefully without fear.
‘Let Us Collectively Strengthen the Rule of Law’
Throughout the interview, Dayal returned to the importance of constitutional democracy, arguing that religious freedom, minority rights and access to justice must be protected through functioning institutions rather than political assurances alone.
His central message was that communities facing discrimination should pursue peaceful and democratic means to defend their rights, while the government and law enforcement agencies must ensure equal treatment under the law.
For Dayal, the issue extends beyond any one religious community. It concerns the fundamental promise of the Indian Constitution: that every citizen should be able to live with dignity, equality and freedom, irrespective of faith.

About Author
Abdullah Salam is an independent multimedia journalist with nearly three years of experience in news reporting, digital storytelling, research and content production. He has contributed to several media outlets, including Clarion India, NNP News, Insaaf Times and Siastat TV.
The Author
Discover more from News Network Plus
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.